Quality of earnings (QoE)
Definition
Quality of earnings is a check on whether a business's reported profit is real, repeatable and matched by cash in the bank. In larger deals an accounting firm writes a formal report. On a small online business the buyer usually does a lighter version themselves: tie revenue to payment data, tie payouts to the bank, and test every adjustment.
Quality of earnings, often shortened to QoE, is the question of how far you can trust a profit figure. Two businesses can both report $20,000 of profit. In one, the money arrives every month from hundreds of subscribers. In the other, half came from a single one-off project. The totals match and the quality does not.
What a quality of earnings check looks at
In a company sale, a QoE report is a document an independent accounting firm prepares for the buyer, the seller or a lender. It restates profit after removing anything unusual and explains each change.
Whoever does the work, the questions are the same:
- Is the revenue real? Does it match the payment provider and the bank?
- Is it recorded in the right period? An annual plan paid in full belongs to twelve months, not one.
- Will it repeat? One-off sales, a viral month and a single large customer all get separated out.
- Are all the costs in? Tools paid on a personal card and unpaid owner time are the usual gaps.
- Do the add-backs hold up?
What it means at this size
A formal report costs real money and takes weeks, so it is rarely commissioned for a business priced in the tens of thousands. That does not make the check optional. It means you do it yourself as part of due diligence, or pay an accountant for a few hours on the parts you are unsure of.
The small-deal version has three steps. Rebuild revenue month by month from payment provider exports. Match the payouts to bank statements. Then list the costs yourself from the bank and card records, without relying on the seller's summary. On Indiemaker a listing can show Revenue Verified when the seller has connected a payment provider, which covers the first question for revenue. Costs and profit remain owner-declared, so the rest is still yours to check. How to verify a seller's revenue sets out the method.
Worked example
A seller declares $17,400 of profit for the trailing twelve months. Going through the records, you find two things. A $1,200 annual plan was counted in full although it was sold in the last month, so $1,100 of it belongs to next year. And $700 of hosting was paid from a personal card and never recorded.
Adjusted profit is $17,400 less $1,100 less $700, so $15,600. Indiemaker's guide range for SaaS is 2.7 to 3.2 times trailing annual profit. It is a guide and not a valuation, but on that range the $1,800 difference moves the figure by between $4,860 and $5,760.
Why it matters when you exit
Sellers can run this check on themselves before listing. Clean the monthly record, spread annual plans properly, put every cost in, and write a line of explanation for each adjustment. A buyer who finds the profit figure holds up on the first pass has less reason to reopen the price. A buyer who finds one error starts looking for the next.
Related: due-diligence, add-backs, sde, trailing-twelve-months
See what a business at this level is listed at.
Everything on sale between $50,000 and $150,000, on the same fields.