How to sell a website: from tidy-up to transfer
The short answer
To sell a website, gather twelve months of traffic and income evidence, work out the profit, set a price on a multiple you can defend, and write a listing that states the weaknesses as plainly as the strengths. Then answer buyers quickly, give read-only access to those who are serious, agree terms in writing, and transfer the site through escrow.
What should you do before you list?
Most of the work in how to sell a website happens before anyone sees the listing. A buyer will ask for the same things in the same order, and a seller who has them ready looks like a lower risk than one who goes looking each time.
Get these in place first:
- Twelve months of income records from the accounts that paid you, month by month.
- Twelve months of traffic in your analytics tool, plus the search console property.
- A list of every cost, with what it is for.
- A list of every asset that will transfer: domain, hosting, content, theme and plugins, email list, social handles the site's terms allow you to pass on, advertising and affiliate arrangements.
- Proof that you own the content. If freelancers wrote it, find the agreements.
- A short written guide to running the site: what gets done weekly, monthly and when something breaks.
Then tidy what a buyer will trip over. Move accounts registered to your personal email onto a business address. Remove plugins nobody uses. Fix the broken pages you have been ignoring. The fuller list is in the selling a business checklist.
Do not start a big redesign or a new income experiment now. Buyers pay for a steady record, and a sudden change shortly before a sale reads as noise.
How do you set the price?
From profit. Add up twelve months of income received, subtract the costs the site needs, and add back your own pay and one-off items. Apply a range for the type of site. Indiemaker's guide range for content sites and newsletters is 2.0 to 2.5 times trailing annual profit, and it is a guide, never a valuation. Stores, software and two-sided platforms have their own ranges, set out in how much is a website worth.
Say your site kept $10,000 over the last twelve months after adjustments. The guide gives $20,000 to $25,000. Where you list inside that depends on the evidence: several traffic sources, steady months and clean records support the upper part. One traffic source or a falling trend belongs lower, and pricing as if the buyer will not notice only delays the same conversation.
Decide your walk-away figure before you list and keep it to yourself.
Where can you sell it?
A listing site, a broker, or a direct sale to someone you already know. Each has a different cost, reach and amount of work, compared in where to sell a website. On Indiemaker, listings are priced from $1,000 to $500,000, the seller pays a success fee out of the sale, and the buyer pays no fee to Indiemaker. The fee is on the pricing page. To start, list your site.
What goes in a good listing?
Facts in the order a buyer checks them.
| Section | What to write |
|---|---|
| What it is | One plain sentence: topic, audience, age |
| How it earns | Each income line and its share of the total |
| The numbers | Twelve months of income, costs and profit, by month |
| Traffic | Monthly visits and the split by source |
| The work | Hours a week, what is done by you and what by contractors |
| What transfers | The asset list |
| Why you are selling | The real reason, briefly |
| Known weaknesses | The dip last spring, the single affiliate programme, the dated theme |
The weaknesses section is the one sellers leave out and buyers find anyway. Stating a problem yourself costs less than having it discovered in diligence, when it also costs you the buyer's trust.
On Indiemaker, revenue can show as Revenue Verified if you connect a payment provider (Stripe, RevenueCat, Paddle, Lemon Squeezy or Polar). Figures you type in are shown as owner-declared. If your income is advertising or affiliate commissions, expect to show those dashboards to serious buyers directly.
How do you deal with buyers?
Answer the same day if you can. Slow replies are the most common reason a sale drifts.
- Give public information freely and private access in stages. Read-only analytics access is reasonable for a buyer who has asked sensible questions. Admin access to anything is not, before completion.
- Ask buyers what they have bought before and how they will pay. You are allowed to qualify them.
- Keep one set of answers. If you tell two buyers different numbers, both will find out.
- Get offers in writing, with the price, the assets and the timetable. A letter of intent does this for larger sales.
Be wary of anyone who wants the site moved before payment, wants to pay in a way that can be reversed, or proposes to pay over time out of the site's future income with nothing securing it.
How do you close and transfer?
- Agree terms in writing: price, asset list, handover support, and what you promise about the figures.
- The buyer pays into escrow. On Indiemaker, payment and handover run through Escrow.com, and the buyer's money is held until the transfer is done.
- Transfer in an agreed order. Copy files and database to the buyer's hosting, add them to analytics and search console, help them swap advertising and affiliate codes, and move the domain last.
- The buyer confirms they control everything, and the funds are released.
- Give the handover support you agreed, for the period you agreed.
The mechanics are in how to transfer website ownership. Keep a private backup until the handover period has ended, then delete it if the agreement says so.
What do sellers get wrong?
They price on revenue or on effort instead of profit. They list before the records are ready. They hide a decline. And they stop running the site once it is listed, so the numbers fall during the sale. Keep operating as if you were not selling, until the day it is no longer yours.
Related: where-to-sell-a-website, how-much-is-a-website-worth, selling-a-business-checklist, sell/website
See what a business at this level is listed at.
Everything on sale between $50,000 and $150,000, on the same fields.