Skip to content

How to buy a website without buying a problem

Indiemaker · Updated 17 November 2026

The short answer

To buy a website, see the traffic inside the analytics and search accounts, not in a screenshot. Trace the income to the networks that pay it, confirm the seller owns the content and the domain, agree a price on trailing profit, and pay through escrow. Take the domain, hosting and accounts into your own name before the money is released.

What are you buying when you buy a website?

You are buying four things that happen to share an address: a domain, the content, the visitors who currently arrive, and the arrangements that turn those visitors into money. Knowing how to buy a website is mostly knowing how to check each of the four separately, because a seller can truthfully own the first two while the last two are already fading.

This guide is about content-led sites: blogs, niche sites, directories, small publications. If the site is really software with logins and subscriptions, read how to acquire a micro-SaaS. If you want only the name, see domains for sale.

Where do you find websites for sale?

On listing sites, through brokers, and by approaching owners directly. A listing site gives you a range to compare. A direct approach gives you a seller with no competing buyers and usually no prepared numbers. On Indiemaker you can browse listings, open a limited number each month for free, and message the seller or make an offer from an opened listing. Every published listing has been checked against our listing standards, which is a floor and not a substitute for your own checks.

How do you check the traffic is real?

Ask for read-only access to the analytics property and the search console property, in your own login. A screenshot or an exported PDF proves nothing. Then look at five things.

  1. Twelve months or more of visits, month by month. One good quarter is a spike, not a trend.
  2. Where visitors come from. A site that gets nearly everything from one search engine, one social platform or one referring site has single-channel dependency.
  3. Which pages bring them. If a handful of pages carry the site, you are buying those pages and a lot of filler.
  4. Which countries. Advertisers pay very different amounts for different audiences.
  5. What the search console shows for queries and positions. Falling positions on the main pages matter more than this month's total.

Compare the two tools against each other and against the hosting logs if you can get them. Numbers from independent systems should roughly agree. How much is traffic worth covers what the visits are worth once you believe them, and traffic quality explains why two sites with the same visit count are not the same asset.

How do you check the income?

Trace each income line to whoever pays it.

Income type Where to see it What to ask
Display advertising The ad network's own dashboard Is the account transferable, or will you need your own approval?
Affiliate commissions Each programme's dashboard Do the terms allow a new owner, and has the commission rate changed?
Sponsored posts or direct ads Invoices and bank deposits Are these repeat buyers or one-offs?
Digital products or memberships The payment provider Are refunds and failed payments netted off?

Then subtract the real costs: hosting, tools, writers, editors, link or advertising spend. What is left over twelve months is the profit a price can be built on. If the seller writes everything personally, a writer's fee belongs in your costs even though it is not in theirs.

Who owns the content?

Ask who wrote it, who took the photographs, and what the agreement was. Content written by freelancers without a written assignment may not be the seller's to sell. Images copied from elsewhere are a claim waiting to arrive at your inbox. Ask whether the site has received takedown notices or manual penalties, and look in the search console for both. Check the backlink profile for links that were paid for, because you inherit the consequences if they are discounted later.

What should you pay?

Start from trailing annual profit. Indiemaker's guide range for content sites and newsletters is 2.0 to 2.5 times trailing annual profit. It is a guide, never a valuation. A hypothetical site that kept $9,000 in the last twelve months sits between $18,000 and $22,500 on that guide, before you adjust for what diligence found. A site with flat or falling traffic, one traffic source or one affiliate programme belongs lower. The full method is in how much is a website worth.

How do you take it over?

Agree the order in writing before any money moves, and pay through escrow. On Indiemaker, payment and handover run through Escrow.com and the buyer's money is held until the transfer is done. A workable order:

  1. Copy the site and database to hosting you control, and test it on a temporary address.
  2. Get added as an owner on analytics, search console and any email list.
  3. Open your own advertising and affiliate accounts, and swap the codes and links.
  4. Move the domain into your registrar account last, then point it at your hosting.
  5. Check the live site, the forms and the income tags, then confirm to escrow.

The domain goes last because it is the one asset that switches everything else. The step-by-step version is in how to transfer website ownership.

What should make you walk away?

A seller who will not give read-only access. Traffic that arrived suddenly from a source nobody can explain. Income that exists only in screenshots. Content the seller cannot show they own. Pressure to pay outside escrow. Any one of these is enough, and a low price does not fix them.

Related: how-much-is-a-website-worth, how-to-buy-a-business, website-flipping, transfer/website

See what a business at this level is listed at.

Everything on sale between $50,000 and $150,000, on the same fields.